CitedEvidence
User Settings
Open AccessArticle

Is Schelling’s Nature-Philosophy Freudian?

Sean McGrath-2011-01-01-The Journal of Macrodynamic Analysis (Memorial University of Newfoundland)

TL;DRAbstract

Marquard has apparently answered the question in our title. But even if we agree that Freud is the early Schelling disenchanted, we can and perhaps must still ask: is a disenchanted Schelling still Schellingian? The question could well be put to Slavoj Žižek, who has carried the disenchantment of Schelling further than anyone else. 1 Žižek shows how Schelling‘s neo-Kabbalistic notion of the contraction of being, which makes the finite order possible (God‘s decision to become a creator and thus bring an end to eternity), mytho-metaphysically dramatizes Lacan‘s developmental psychology: after the cut of the logos, the interdiction of the Father (le nom/non du Pere), the pre-Oedipal unity of the child with the mother contracts into the ineffable and inassimilable ―real‖ so that symbolically mediated ego-life can begin. To be sure, Žižek does not claim that Lacan‘s psychoanalysis is based on Schelling; rather, he claims, that Schelling can be fruitfully read through Lacan. There is however

Chat with Paper

AI Agents for this Paper

Marquard has apparently answered the question in our title. But even if we agree that Freud is the early Schelling disenchanted, we can and perhaps must still ask: is a disenchanted Schelling still Schellingian? The question could well be put to Slavoj Žižek, who has carried the disenchantment of Schelling further than anyone else. 1 Žižek shows how Schelling‘s neo-Kabbalistic notion of the contraction of being, which makes the finite order possible (God‘s decision to become a creator and thus bring an end to eternity), mytho-metaphysically dramatizes Lacan‘s developmental psychology: after the cut of the logos, the interdiction of the Father (le nom/non du Pere), the pre-Oedipal unity of the child with the mother contracts into the ineffable and inassimilable ―real‖ so that symbolically mediated ego-life can begin. To be sure, Žižek does not claim that Lacan‘s psychoanalysis is based on Schelling; rather, he claims, that Schelling can be fruitfully read through Lacan. There is however

Keywords

Freudian slipEternityPhilosophyPsychoanalysisLogos Bible SoftwareId, ego and super-egoEpistemologyLiterature

Chat

Click to start Chat